diff --git a/gemp-lotr/gemp-lotr-async/src/main/web/includes/changeLog.html b/gemp-lotr/gemp-lotr-async/src/main/web/includes/changeLog.html
index d6a7ca25d..eee354545 100644
--- a/gemp-lotr/gemp-lotr-async/src/main/web/includes/changeLog.html
+++ b/gemp-lotr/gemp-lotr-async/src/main/web/includes/changeLog.html
@@ -1,4 +1,7 @@
 <pre style="font-size:80%">
+<b>7 Mar. 2013</b>
+- "Arwen", "Echo of Luthien" now applies its -3 penalty only if the card was actually ELVEN.
+
 <b>5 Mar. 2013</b>
 - "Bilbo", "Bearer of Things Burgled" and any card that allows a choice of adding twilight now correctly displays
 the effect text.
diff --git a/gemp-lotr/gemp-lotr-cards/src/main/java/com/gempukku/lotro/cards/set10/elven/Card10_005.java b/gemp-lotr/gemp-lotr-cards/src/main/java/com/gempukku/lotro/cards/set10/elven/Card10_005.java
index e29b37536..28671f132 100644
--- a/gemp-lotr/gemp-lotr-cards/src/main/java/com/gempukku/lotro/cards/set10/elven/Card10_005.java
+++ b/gemp-lotr/gemp-lotr-cards/src/main/java/com/gempukku/lotro/cards/set10/elven/Card10_005.java
@@ -45,9 +45,9 @@ public class Card10_005 extends AbstractCompanion {
                         @Override
                         protected void discardedCardCallback(PhysicalCard card) {
                             if (card.getBlueprint().getCulture() == Culture.ELVEN) {
+                                action.appendEffect(
+                                        new AddUntilEndOfPhaseModifierEffect(new StrengthModifier(self, Filters.and(CardType.MINION, Filters.inSkirmishAgainst(self)), -3)));
                             }
-                            action.appendEffect(
-                                    new AddUntilEndOfPhaseModifierEffect(new StrengthModifier(self, Filters.and(CardType.MINION, Filters.inSkirmishAgainst(self)), -3)));
                         }
                     });
             return Collections.singletonList(action);